The short answer: strong B2B positioning comes from three decisions:
- lead a category you can own, rather than fighting to be slightly better in someone else’s;
- own a specific problem, described in your customers’ words;
- write it into a ratified document that sales, marketing and your agencies all work from.
Tactics can’t fix a positioning problem. They only amplify it.
Here’s a diagnostic you can run before lunch. I call it the Any-Three-People Test. Separately ask your CEO, your top salesperson and your marketing coordinator (or agency account manager) three questions:
- What problem do we solve better than anyone else?
- Who is our ideal buyer, and why should they choose us over our top two competitors?
- What category do we lead?
In many growing companies, the three answers don’t match. The founder talks about product and vision; the salesperson talks about price and custom features, because that’s what closes the deal in front of them; and the website says something safe and generic, like “innovative, end-to-end, customer-centric solutions.”
When positioning lives in one person’s head, or doesn’t exist at all, every dollar spent on ads, SEO, events and outbound sales works at a fraction of its potential. Having learned positioning directly from Al Ries, and applied it across 16 years and two international Gold awards for brand work, I’m convinced of one thing: tactical marketing can’t fix a positioning failure.
What’s the difference between positioning, messaging and taglines?
Many executives assume positioning means a new logo, a fresh colour palette and a clever homepage tagline. Visual identity matters, but it’s the packaging of positioning, not the positioning itself.
Al Ries and Jack Trout made the point in Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind: positioning isn’t something you do to a product; it’s what you do in the mind of the prospect. Buyers, especially cautious B2B buyers in technology, financial services and regulated industries, are overloaded with information. To cope, they rank options on a short mental “ladder” for each category, with room for only one or two trusted names at the top.
- Positioning is the strategic decision about which ladder you’ll climb (or build) and which problem you own in the buyer’s mind.
- Messaging is how you express that position, using your customers’ own language, objections and desired outcomes.
- Copy and taglines are the surface expressions used in ads, landing pages and sales decks.
Rewrite your website without settling the positioning underneath, and you’re repainting a house built on sand.
Principle 1: Create a category instead of fighting for share in someone else’s
When an established competitor already holds the top of the ladder in your market, claiming to be slightly better, faster or cheaper rarely works. Buyers are sceptical of “better,” and the claim drags your sales team into feature-by-feature comparisons and price wars.
The higher-leverage move is category creation: defining a narrower, more specific category you can lead outright. Ways to do it:
- Specialize by problem. Instead of being one of thousands of “managed IT providers,” become, for example, the compliance-first IT and security partner for regulated wealth management firms.
- Name the old way. Strong category plays contrast the buyer’s current frustration with a new approach. Once you’ve explained clearly why the old way fails, competitors still selling it are measured against your definition.
- Own the vocabulary. Coin the terms buyers use to evaluate the problem. Whoever defines the criteria for the decision has an advantage in it.
Principle 2: Position around the problem you solve, not demographics
A classic trap is building buyer personas on surface demographics: age, job title, hobbies, favourite coffee. In B2B and other considered purchases, demographics rarely explain why someone buys. Two companies with the same revenue, headcount and industry can have opposite needs.
Instead, position around the specific problem customers need solved. To find it, talk to your front-line sales reps, customer success team, and your last ten won and lost deals. Capture the exact phrases buyers used to describe what was broken before they found you. When your headlines, emails and sales decks echo what a frustrated buyer is already thinking, trust comes quickly.
Principle 3: Build “constitutional cohesiveness” across sales and marketing
Even excellent positioning dies if it lives in a PDF that nobody opens two weeks after the workshop. When people leave, the knowledge leaves with them, and new hires and agencies go back to improvising.
To prevent that drift, I work with leadership teams to write their positioning into a living, ratified marketing constitution. It typically includes:
- Category and problem statement: one ratified paragraph on the category you lead, the problem you remove and the outcome you deliver.
- Value pillars and proof: your three core differentiators, each backed by evidence such as case studies, credentials and results, not adjectives.
- Objection handling: the top objections raised in discovery calls, with the reframes both marketing and sales use to answer them.
- Voice, tone and banned words: how the brand speaks, including the buzzwords agencies and copywriters aren’t allowed to fall back on.
Once leadership ratifies it, the constitution becomes the filter for every campaign idea, agency brief and sales deck. If a proposal doesn’t reinforce it, it doesn’t get funded.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between brand positioning, messaging and a tagline?
Positioning is the strategic decision about which category you lead and which problem you own in the buyer’s mind. Messaging expresses that position in your customers’ own language. A tagline is one short creative expression of it. Change taglines without settling positioning and nothing underneath changes.
What is category creation in B2B marketing?
Category creation means defining a narrower, more specific category you can lead outright, instead of competing to be slightly better in a category a larger competitor already owns. It works best when you name the old way of doing things and show why it fails.
Should B2B positioning be built on buyer personas?
Demographic personas rarely explain why businesses buy. Two companies with the same size and industry can have very different needs. Position around the specific problem your best customers needed solved, in the words they used to describe it.
How do you keep positioning consistent across sales and marketing?
Write it down and give it authority. A marketing constitution, ratified by leadership, records the category, problem statement, proof points, objection handling and voice rules, and becomes the standard every campaign, agency brief and sales deck is checked against.
If your team gives three different answers to “what do we do?”, that’s where I start every engagement. Book a discovery call or read more about my approach.
Sources
- Al Ries and Jack Trout, Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind (book notes and key ideas)
